Matthew Trusler's Mendelssohn

Playing on a 1711 Stradivarius with one of Heifetz’s bows and having studied with Ruggiero Ricci, young violinist Matthew Trusler playing the Mendelssohn's violin concerto became the main attraction in this HK sinfonietta concert (at least to me). Little did I know that it was in fact the highlight of the whole evening. Honestly, it was not outstanding already. So it showed how disappointing this concert was.

The concert started with a commissioned new orchestral work by local composer George Lam. I admire and respect these new commissions for local young composers from time to time by HKS (while HKPO have the resources but no guts to do so). "The Queen's Gramophone", as the composer himself explained briefly on stage before its world premiere performance, is his imaginative "recollection" of our Hong Kong in the 1960s. How this young composer can write something about the place he left when he was 10 and about the era before his birth is beyond my understanding. Anyway, the music started with a slow and "lazy" dance melody (partly French and partly Spanish style to me) introduced by the bassoon over the pizzicato bass. The melody then was developed with transformation in terms of rhythm, harmonisation and instrumention, until it was chaotic enough to be recognised in the climax. Afterwards, the clarinet introduced the refreshing and jazzy dance music over the mellow brass, which interestingly have a similar texture of Wong Kar Wai's film music. The music however gradually and slowly died away in the end.

Yip Wing-sie's interpretation and leading was a bit plain and cautious, and the tempo changes were not done well and convincingly. A little more imagination and flexibility would be better for this "soundtrack-like" music. It didn't do the music enough justice, for it could neither stimulate emotion nor image from the audience. The bassoon and clarinet did quite well for their solo passages nevertheless.

In the Mendelssohn's violin concerto, Trusler's violin produced a distinctively sharp and penetrative sound. While many young soloists try to play this piece slower and to drill on the details, Trusler played it in a faster pace and in a straight-forward way as if it's a classical period music. He didn't use the vibrato excessively, and he avoided the temptation to romanticize the 2nd movement like everyone else nowadays. Instead, he concentrated on the momentum and articulation of the music. I found his spiccato especially amazing, and resulted in a red-hot exciting and vibrant final movement. Having said that, some very high notes were not steadily reached, and he even somehow resorted to "cheating" by using slides unnecessarily, which I strongly protested. The orchestra was not helping much either, as it was lagging behind the soloist slightly most of the time. Anyhow, in response to the warm applause of the audience, he jokingly said that he wishes to move here before awarded us the virtuosic scherzo by Kreisler, which sounded very well indeed (though not as Zino):

However, nothing prepared me for the disappointing Beethoven's 8th Symphony after the intermission. The tempo was too fast (I guess no one would stick to Beethoven's "crazy" metronomic indications nowadays for the big modern orchestra!), the "thick" sound too poorly controlled that it's intimidating and even suffocating. All I could experience was the repeated rhythmic strong blows to my head throughout without any harmonic layering or fine orchestral details shown, which were all lost in the forcefully energised propulsion. Maybe I don't understand fully and I can't appreciate them enough, but I thought Beethoven's 8th is one of his "smallest" and "lightest" symphonies until I heard it performed by HKS under Yip Wing-sie that evening........Now I'm beginning to admire and miss their playing of the Pastoral Symphony last month.

Hong Kong Sinfonietta concert
6th Nov 2009 8pm at HK City Hall Concert Hall
Music Director/Conductor: Yip Wing-sie
Violin: Matthew Trusler

Programme:

George Tsz-kwan Lam	The Queen's Gramophone (world première)
Mendelssohn	Violin Concerto in E minor, Op 64
Beethoven	Symphony No 8 in F, Op 93

Freddy Kempf and Hong Kong Sinfonietta

Only a week after Schumann's violin concerto performed by Blacher and HKPO, Schumann's much more popular piano concerto was staged at the same place the past Saturday by Hong Kong Sinfonietta together with virtuosic young pianist Freddy Kempf.

The concert opened with a purely string ensemble piece - a collection of 3 film scores by famous Japanese contemporary composer Takemitsu. This set of three film scores is among the most popular works of the composer and is widely performed around the world nowadays (recently played in Beijing by the Abbado's Lucerne Festival Orchestra). And I think it's a perfect repertoire to kick off this HKS's concert, considering their Japanese guest conductor Hirokami of the evening.

The small string ensemble, with guest concertmaster James Cuddeford (of Grainger Quartet again), showed their precision and intimacy in the playing, while the conductor put most of his energy and stress on the dynamic changes, rhythmic changes and the musical phrasing. The resulted music was lively and infectious, especially the final waltz. However, Hirokami at the same time uncontrollably produced some audibly disturbing breathing sound all the way, mixing together with the fine orchestral sound while conducting.

Luckily, with Freddy Kempf brought onto the stage for Schumann's piano concerto, his breathing sound was somehow lightened and reduced with some self restraint. Right from the start of the first movement of the concerto, it was clear that Kempf was giving us a more inhibited, introverted and a very melancholic playing instead of the schizophrenic Schumann we're familiar with. The main theme was introduced in a much slower pace but full of intense nostalgia and meditation. His playing was very well articulated with exquisite intonation and expressive phrasing, especially marked in the second movement.

Sometimes his tasteful rubato, ritardando and thoughtful tempo change gave the music a further impressive impact and genius touch. What's more astonishing was the orchestra's chamber-like accompaniment, giving the soloist close support and interaction from time to time. Though not quite explosive and dazzling in the final movement, Kempf's virtuosic fingerworks served the finale well and fast enough. Overall, with the emotional contrasts deliberately tuned down, the concerto was successfully executed with Kempf's overpowering musicality shining through and winning over his solid piano technique. That was responded by audience's thunderous applause in recognition, and in return we were treated with a Chopin's equally musicality-over-technique Etude as an encore. (By the way, I think it's the best Schumann piano concerto version I've witnessed live so far. My only complaint would be the problematic French horns, while the clarinet stays as my favourite among the wind instruments that evening.)

The Pastoral by Beethoven in the second half of the concert was painted with very broad stroke overall, missing some fine details in between, more so in the slower second movement. This was in fact visually evident when the bass section of the strings of HKS was much expanded with freelance players after the intermission. While the conductor was concentrating on steadier and tighter tempo control, aiming for a grand or sometimes ecstatic atmosphere, the sense of spontaneity and freshness that this symphony badly required were sacrificed, resulted in somehow uncomfortably exaggerated dynamics, and even unnaturally overwhelming orchestral sound. It sounded like they were playing the Eroica! Nonetheless, the conductor (apart from his annoying heavy breathe sounds) led the orchestra very well, with good syncopation and unity, and his gestures for phrasing and giving cues to each section was done efficiently and accurately. All in all, while the execution was smooth and satisfactory, it lacked the appropriate musical sense, atmosphere and fine details that this great masterpiece demands.

10 October 2009 8pm
Hong Kong City Hall Concert Hall

Conductor - Junichi Hirokami
Pianist - Freddy Kempf

Takemitsu - Three film scores
Schumann - Piano Concerto in A minor
Beethoven - Symphony no.6 "Pastoral"

Hong Kong Sinfonietta with the Grainger Quartet

It was quite a pleasant experience to listen to the Baroque music (apart from the Dvorak's and Grieg's, of course) performed by the Hong Kong Sinfonietta last Sunday evening.

The Baroque music, including famous works by Bach, Vivaldi and Marcello are truly ingenious. They are very well structured but still have their lively mood and entertaining value. In short, highly refreshing and relaxing for the listeners!

Bach's Brandenburg Concerto no.3, for example, never fails to cheer up the crowd. I've known this lovely music for a very long time, but this was the first time I witnessed it performed live. And the effect was mind-blowing......I discovered that it was much more complicated and riveting than I originally expected. In fact, the nine instruments (3 violins, 3 violas and 3 cellos) each have its own chances to play solo phrases alternately but on the whole they harmoniously combine and generate a spectacular and continuous musical flow. Though the final movement was played a bit too rushed and at times a bit chaotic that night.

Vivaldi, though well-known for his "four seasons" concerti, had also written another famous concerto for 4 violins (Op3, No.10), and it's so famous that Bach even made a transcription of it for 4 harpsichords (or pianos are used sometimes nowadays) instead. Try to imagine : to write a concerto featuring 4 violinists, competing and supporting each other simultaneously! That would be quite a challenge, but Vivaldi (not unlike Bach when he wrote the above mentioned concerto) made it such a great fun for the 4 violinists to play together and still have some virtuosic solo moment for each one. The music is very easily assimilated, and it's exciting to see the 4 soloists playing side by side in the front of the stage, with the orchestra accompanying at the back. Marvelous experience for me, except that one of the soloists was too nervous and sounded a bit uptight and flat occasionally.

Marcello is not a familiar name to most music lovers nowadays, especially among all those giants in the Baroque period, but his concerto for oboe alone could leave his mark in the history, with its enchanting slow movement pretty popular even in the Hollywood industry as the movie soundtrack. I was glad to listen to the complete concerto that night, with Peter Cooper playing the oboe wonderfully. I simply couldn't complain......

Finally, the Strings of HKS, led by the Grainger Quartet with each at the front of the respective sections, gave us Grieg's Holberg Suite, an imitation and dedication to the Baroque period music by the romantic Nordic composer. Similar to the other pieces of the evening, it is a very easy-listening music, and the performance was magnificent. I guess the input by Grainger Quartet must have played a part there (Yip Wing Sze is very brilliant to come up with the idea of having this Quartet as their Artist Associate this year!), but I still have to admire HKS's string players for their commitment, effort and progress throughout the years. And for encore, their playing of Mozart could put HKPO to shame, I dare say......



Grainger Quartet (Artist Associate, Hong Kong Sinfonietta 07/08 season)
Natsuko Yoshimoto (Violin)
James Cuddeford (Violin)
Jeremy Williams (Viola)
Patrick Murphy (Cello)
Special Guest: Peter Cooper* (Oboe Principal of Colorado Symphony Orchestra)

Programme
Bach Brandenburg Concerto No 3 in G, BWV1048
Dvorák Wind Serenade in D minor, Op 44
Vivaldi Concerto in B minor for 4 violins from L’Estro Armonico, RV580 (Op 3 No 10)
(Violin solo: Natsuko Yoshimoto, James Cuddeford, Jensen Lung, Eiko Hosaka)
Marcello Oboe Concerto in C minor*
Grieg Holberg Suite, Op 40